Target Shoppers Are In for a Sweet Surprise
For dessert lovers, the best part of a grocery run is often picking up a special treat. And now, thanks to Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches, that treat is about to get even sweeter. The beloved ice cream sandwich brand, known for its rich and creative flavors, is launching its famous frozen desserts in over 370 Target stores across the United States. This marks a major milestone for Nightingale, making its cult-favorite ice cream sandwiches available at one of the nation’s biggest retailers for the first time.
For those who’ve experienced the magic of Nightingale, this rollout is nothing short of exciting. The company’s ice cream sandwiches have been fan favorites for years, and now more customers can enjoy them at their convenience. This is the brand’s second major retail launch, following a highly successful stint at Costco stores, where Nightingale’s treats flew off the shelves faster than most could say “Cookie Monster.”
Starting October 17, shoppers at Target will find a full shelf of Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches in the freezer aisles across key markets, including the Northeast, Denver, Colorado, Dallas, Texas, and more. This is a significant expansion for the company, which was previously only available in select locations and online.
A Game-Changing Partnership
Hannah Pollack, CEO and co-founder of Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches, spoke to Food & Wine about the excitement surrounding the Target launch. She explained that the partnership marks a new chapter for the brand. “The Costco partnership was such an exciting step forward in bringing our sandwiches to a broader audience, but with Target, it’s about being part of people’s everyday lives,” she said. “This launch feels incredibly special because it represents our continued growth and commitment to making our products available to everyone.”
Pollack’s vision for Nightingale is clear: to be a household name, not just a seasonal or occasional treat. With Target, the brand isn’t just aiming for a quick retail hit. Pollack confirmed that this partnership is meant to be long-term, providing shoppers with consistent access to their favorite ice cream sandwiches.
Nightingale’s Unique Offerings: A Flavor for Every Taste
Nightingale Ice Cream Sandwiches has already earned a reputation for its creative and mouthwatering flavors. At Target, shoppers will be able to pick up five delicious varieties, including four fan favorites and one new flavor that’s still a rarity on the market.
Here’s a rundown of the flavors you can expect to see:
- The Classic – Made with Madagascar vanilla bean ice cream sandwiched between chewy brownie cookies, this classic flavor is an all-time favorite that never goes out of style. It’s the perfect choice for those who appreciate a no-fuss, delicious treat.
- Cookie Monster – Featuring chocolate chip cookies and cookie crumb-infused vanilla ice cream, this flavor is a true crowd-pleaser. It’s a playful take on a traditional cookie and ice cream combination that has become a signature offering from Nightingale.
- Strawberry Shortcake – For fans of fruity and sweet desserts, this flavor pairs golden brown sugar cookies with strawberry ice cream. The balance of flavors makes it a refreshing and indulgent treat that’s perfect for any occasion.
- Chocolate Blackout – For the ultimate chocolate lover, the Chocolate Blackout flavor delivers a decadent experience with chocolate brownie cookies, chocolate ganache swirl ice cream, and chocolate cake pieces. It’s a rich, multi-layered dessert that hits all the right notes for a chocolate craving.
- Brookie Dough – This new flavor is one of Nightingale’s most special creations yet. Combining a chocolate brownie cookie with a chocolate chip cookie and chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream, the Brookie Dough sandwich is a flavor-packed indulgence that’s sure to be a hit. Target shoppers will be able to grab this flavor in a unique “chomp-size,” which features miniature, single-serving versions of the sandwiches.
According to Pollack, the Brookie Dough flavor is something the company is especially proud of, calling it one of the “most special products we’ve ever created.” And for those who can’t get enough of the flavor, the chomp-size versions provide an ideal way to enjoy a sweet treat without committing to a full-size sandwich.
Crafting the Perfect Ice Cream Sandwich
What sets Nightingale apart from other ice cream sandwich brands is the attention to detail in its ingredients and production process. Unlike mass-produced options, Nightingale prides itself on making every cookie from scratch and crafting its ice cream in small batches with high-quality ingredients. There are no artificial additives, and the ice cream used in Nightingale sandwiches boasts 14% butterfat, which gives it a creamy, indulgent texture that stands out in every bite.
The brand’s meticulous process starts with the cookies. Each one is made with care and baked to a perfect softness, even after being frozen. The ice cream is crafted in small batches in the company’s Richmond, Virginia facility, and each sandwich is carefully wrapped and prepared to ensure the highest quality.
Pollack explains, “Everything about our process is intentional — we control our overrun, use 14% butterfat ice cream, and every cookie sandwich is built and wrapped with care right in our facility. We want our customers to experience the same perfect sandwich every time.”
From Costco to Target: A Rapid Expansion
Nightingale’s growth has been swift, thanks to its exceptional products and loyal following. After launching its Cookie Monster Ice Cream Sandwiches at Costco in July 2024, the brand became a viral sensation. The sandwiches sold out in just one week, prompting a restock in the summer of 2025. The popularity of the flavor, combined with the buzz surrounding Nightingale’s unique offerings, led to the current retail expansion into Target stores.
The decision to move into Target represents a significant shift for Nightingale, as the brand now has the opportunity to reach a much broader audience. With Target’s nationwide reach, Nightingale is poised to become a staple in freezers across the country. And with several of their most popular flavors now available at Target, it’s clear that the brand is ready for the next phase of its journey.
Looking Forward
With the Target launch beginning on October 17, there’s no doubt that Nightingale’s ice cream sandwiches will be in high demand. Fans of the brand are already anticipating the release, and many are eager to see if the sandwiches will be as popular as they were at Costco.
Pollack’s team is ready for the challenge, ensuring that the shelves are well-stocked and that customers can easily find their favorite flavors. And with the promise of new and exciting products to come, it’s clear that Nightingale’s sweet journey is just getting started.
